Harshad Mehta Scam vs Modern Market Surveillance
When the Harshad Mehta scam unfolded in 1992, a stock could reportedly climb from around Rs 200 to around Rs 9,000 without any automatic system stepping in to question what was happening. Today’s markets look very different. This post compares, in general terms, how market oversight in 1992 compares to oversight now, without getting into the technical details of specific current tools.
What oversight looked like in 1992
In the early 1990s, India’s stock exchanges and banking system relied heavily on manual processes and paper documentation. Bank receipts were accepted largely on trust. There was no real time system flagging unusual price movement in specific stocks as it happened. Problems tended to surface only after they had already grown large, often through investigative journalism rather than internal detection, as happened when Sucheta Dalal’s reporting exposed the scheme in April 1992.
This reliance on manual review also meant that connecting the dots between different institutions took much longer. A fraudulent pattern that touched several banks and multiple stocks could sit undetected for an extended period simply because no single person or system had a complete view across all of these pieces at once. Detection depended on someone noticing an inconsistency and then having the persistence to dig further, rather than on an automated process flagging the pattern immediately.
What changed in the years after
Following the scam, and the reforms that came with it, Indian markets gradually moved toward electronic trading and settlement. This reduced some of the paper based trust problems that the scam exploited. Exchanges and regulators also began building tools meant to catch unusual trading patterns earlier, rather than relying mainly on outside exposure.
This shift did not happen in a single step. It took years of infrastructure building, policy changes, and a gradual move away from older manual processes across the whole financial system. Each step of this transition reduced one more way that paper based trust could be quietly exploited, even though the full picture of this change spans a long period rather than a single reform event.
How modern surveillance differs in spirit
Without getting into the specific technical mechanics of today’s monitoring systems, the broad shift has been from reactive to more proactive oversight. In 1992, a stock could run up for an extended period before anyone outside a small circle questioned it. Modern exchanges have mechanisms, generally grouped under the idea of market surveillance, that are designed to flag sharp or unusual price and volume activity in individual stocks much sooner.
Circuit breakers, which pause trading in a stock or the whole market after a sharp move, are one visible example of this shift toward building automatic brakes into the system, rather than relying only on people noticing something is wrong.
The general philosophy behind modern surveillance is to catch problems while they are still small, rather than after they have grown to a scale that threatens the whole market. This is a meaningful shift in mindset compared to 1992, where the system had essentially no automatic mechanism for noticing a problem until it had already become very large.
What stayed the same
Even with better tools, markets are still made of people, and people are still capable of chasing a rising price without asking why it is rising. Surveillance systems can slow down or flag extreme moves, but they cannot fully remove the underlying behavior of traders getting pulled into a story, the same behavior we discuss in our post on the behavioral lessons from this scam. No amount of regulatory sophistication can substitute for a trader’s own independent judgment in the moment a decision is actually made. That judgment remains the one thing every trader must still supply for themselves, no matter how good the surrounding systems become.
Why this comparison matters for traders today
It is tempting to think that because better systems exist now, a 1992 style event is impossible today. That is probably too confident a claim. Better surveillance reduces certain kinds of risk, particularly the kind built on hidden paperwork fraud, but it does not remove the risk of a trader personally getting caught up in a hot narrative around a stock. The tools have improved. Human behavior has not changed nearly as much.
New kinds of financial products and new trading venues also tend to create fresh gaps that older surveillance systems were not built to watch for. Regulators generally have to adapt their tools over time as the market itself changes, which means surveillance is more of an ongoing process than a finished solution. A system built to catch one kind of problem well is not automatically equipped to catch a different kind of problem that has not appeared yet.
A balanced view
The honest takeaway is that markets today have meaningfully better infrastructure for catching extreme and unusual activity than they did in 1992. That is a real improvement. At the same time, no system fully protects an individual trader from their own decision making under pressure, which is why understanding your own psychology still matters as much as understanding the rules around you.
Treating better surveillance as a reason to lower your own guard would be a mistake. The strongest position for any individual trader is to combine respect for the structural improvements that now exist with a continued, personal discipline around how you make decisions, since the system can flag extreme activity, but it cannot make your individual choices for you.
Frequently asked questions
Could the exact mechanism of the Harshad Mehta scam work today?
The specific loophole involving fake bank receipts has been targeted by reforms since 1992, making that particular path much harder. We are not qualified to say any fraud mechanism is fully impossible today.
What is a circuit breaker in simple terms?
It is a rule that pauses trading, in a stock or across the market, after a sharp price move, giving the market a brief pause rather than letting momentum run unchecked.
Does better surveillance mean trading is safer now?
It reduces certain structural risks seen in 1992, but it does not remove the risk that comes from a trader’s own decisions and emotions during fast moving markets.
Is this a technical guide to current surveillance systems?
No, this post only offers a general comparison. Samir Dash is not a SEBI-registered investment advisor, and nothing on this blog is investment advice, for specific financial decisions, consult a SEBI-registered advisor. Read the full disclaimer.
Systems improve, par apna dimaag sambhalna hamesha apni zimmedari hai.
Want to fix the decision-making gap that no strategy course ever covers? Join Samir Dash’s free masterclass on trading psychology and decision-making under pressure: Reserve your free seat here.
Samir Dash is the founder of Mindful Trading Hub, helping experienced traders build the discipline to trade consistently. Learn more at samirdash.in.